Why Insider Buying Matters (and When It Doesn't)
What research says about insider purchases, why buys are a stronger signal than sales, and the kinds of insider buys that tell you little.
By Ticker Press · Updated November 16, 2026
Insiders know their company better than anyone outside it. They see the order book, the product pipeline and the cash position every week. When one of them takes their own money and buys more shares on the open market, it is reasonable to ask why. This guide explains what an insider purchase can and cannot tell you.
Buys say more than sales
There are many reasons to sell a stock: paying taxes on vested shares, buying a house, diversifying a fortune that sits in one company, a divorce. There is basically one reason to buy it on the open market: you think it is worth more than the price. That asymmetry is why Ticker Press tracks purchases only.
What academic research has found
Insider trading data has been studied for decades. Two widely cited findings are useful to keep in mind:
- Josef Lakonishok and Inmoo Lee (“Are Insider Trades Informative?”, Review of Financial Studies, 2001) found that insider purchases, not sales, were followed by better-than-average returns, and that the effect was concentrated in smaller companies.
- Lauren Cohen, Christopher Malloy and Lukasz Pomorski (“Decoding Inside Information”, Journal of Finance, 2012) separated “routine” insiders, who trade at the same time every year, from “opportunistic” ones. The routine trades carried no useful information; the opportunistic ones did.
Both studies describe averages over thousands of trades. They do not mean that any single insider purchase will make money, and markets change once an effect is widely known.
Signals that tend to carry more weight
- Several insiders buying at once. One person can be wrong or have a personal reason. When the CEO, the CFO and two directors all buy in the same month, that is a cluster buy.
- Size relative to the insider's holding. The “Stake” column shows how much a purchase increased the insider's position. Doubling a stake is a stronger statement than adding 2%.
- Size relative to the person. $50,000 means more from a director of a small company than from a billionaire founder.
- Buying after bad news or a falling price. Insiders buying into weakness are telling you they disagree with the market. They can still be early, or wrong.
- Officers with operating knowledge. A CFO or CEO usually knows more about the next quarter than an outside director.
Buys that tell you less
- Pre-scheduled trades under a Rule 10b5-1 plan. The decision was made months earlier.
- Private placements and offerings (our private tag). The insider bought new shares from the company, often as part of a financing round that needed their participation.
- Funds that are 10% owners. A venture or activist fund adding to a position can be a strong view, but it can also be routine portfolio management, follow-on investments or support for a company in trouble. Their reasons are different from an executive's.
- Token purchases. Small buys right after joining a board, or the same small amount every year, are often about showing commitment rather than a view on the price.
- Penny stocks. At very low prices, a purchase can be a lifeline to a struggling company rather than a bet on a recovery.
How to use insider data well
Treat an insider purchase as a reason to look closer, not a reason to buy. Read the filing, check the footnotes, look at the company's recent results and debt, and ask why the insider might be buying now. Our “Since buy” column shows how past purchases have done, but past results do not predict future ones.
Ticker Press is information, not advice. Insiders are often early and sometimes simply wrong.
More guides
Get insider buys on TelegramFree daily recap of the biggest insider purchases, straight from SEC filings. Real-time alerts for Premium members.
Join free on Telegram